Nitride vs phosphate barrel

The nitride rifle cost $45 more, which seems very well worth it. These days the nitride rifle is the only one being shot much. At first it was difficult to leave it uncleaned over night, then for a day, then for another day. Now, it is common to be left for a few days without cleaning. No issues. The need to clean the breech plug, kinda ...Cerakote vs. Xylan®. We put Cerakote Elite Blackout and Xylan® coated bolts and hex nuts in the salt chamber to test who would finish strong against red-rust corrosion. At 540 hours, the Xylan® coated items reached, per Cerakote Standard ASTM D610, 3% red-rust on the body of the bolts and were left in chamber for later comparison. The Xylan ...Go nitride if you can. Phosphate has a rougher surface, it's good at trapping oil and I DO recommend you keep it well oiled. Nitride is slicker and has better rust resistance, im not sure if it's any better for wear but ya.. go nitirde if you can. NITRIDE!!!!! Go nitride, they are maybe $5 more and well worth it.It has their QPQ finish which is essentially a nitride treatment. QPQ is quench, polish, quench. It is extremely slick and cleans up with the wipe of a rag. DLC on the other hand is a coating as is hard chrome. Nitride is a surface treatment. Any of them are superior to phosphate. Posted: 9/15/2019 11:22:57 AM EDT.Apr 10, 2024 · DLC outperforms nitride by about the same amount that nitride outperforms phosphate. This is on the basis of hardness and corrosion resistance. It is just a question of how much performance you want to pay for. Both are far beyond ordinary. On the basis of bang for the buck, nitride wins. If you have the money, DLC wins. DLC vs PhosphateNitride vs Phosphate. PSA ProductsAR-15. GuitarGuy July 17, 2021, 11:33pm 2. I prefer Nitride simply for its corrosion resistance. 5 Likes. show post in topic. I have read some about Nitride and Phosphate barrels. I was wondering if you guys have a preference?Phosphate is a metal treatment to impart corrosion resistance. Still one of the better finishes on the market for someone making a "hard use" rifle. Melonite is a a metal treatment to impart corrosion resistance which also has the added benefit of being hard and "slick" very similar to chrome, which will allow the bore to last longer than that …Phosphate has more texture, which holds oil but produces its own friction. Nitride might on average be less hard than phosphate depending on treatment quality, but basically never in a way that would matter to you. The amount of time the difference will ever matter to you is close to zero.Hrd Chrme 88hrs Appx 80%. 3. Full QPQ nitride 336hrs Appx 10%. 4. Nitride non QPQ 88Hrs Appx 5%. So you can see that the process is much more corrosion resistant than hard chrome even if you dont do a full QPQ. you must do the the full QPQ on all gun parts to get the maximum corrosion resistance and best appearance on all parts.Both work very well however, Chrome lining is a bit tougher in extended fire (auto fire). Nitriding can yield a more accurate barrel, as there is NO coating in the bore. Nitriding cleans better, has a smoother & ”cleaner” look to it, when compared to the phosphate outer surface of a Chrome-lined barrel.Go with the FN. Most FN barrel PSA AKs so have an ALG trigger. Factor that in as well. I believe FN barrels are double chrome lined. And nitride barrels are not. If I'm not mistaken, it's phosphate finish outside. So it may rust if not taken care. But once in a while wipe some oil on it.Cracker Barrel Old Country Store is a beloved American restaurant chain known for its homestyle cooking and cozy country atmosphere. With over 650 locations across the United State...A great barrel is absolutely worth the cost. It is the single most important part of any rifle. Stainless steel should not cost any more or any significant amount more than any other material steel. prefer the black nitride look Many stainless steel barrels can be nitrided black, and all can be painted black if you want black. That's easy.PSA AR-15 Pistol Uppers vs Mid-Length Gas System Barrels are Nitride coated which has a nice smooth black color but isn't too shiny. PSA's nitride barrels are their middle-of-the-road barrels. ... Coloring matches up for both my uppers and I like the Nitride barrel compared to Phosphate (bumpy and dull). Customization: 5/5.Chrome lined barrels handle heat better than CMV, SS or Nitride/Melonite/QPQ CMV/SS barrels. The chrome is applied over a rifled bore so there can a variation of thickness of the chrome. A little harder to hold tolerance when applying chrome to a rifled bore which can affect the accuracy of the barrel. Chrome Lined …PSA Nitride did just as good as the CHF Chrome lined barrels in the meltdown test. Nitride all the way. 1 to 7 is a good twist rate if you want to shoot the heavier 77 grain ammo and works well with the green tips. 1/8 is a little better for the 55 grain stuff.We speak with Nathanial from Faxon regarding barrels, barrel manufacturing, chrome lining versus nitride and more.If you're interested in learning what reall...Phosphate > chrome lined > chrome line bore and chamber. The barrel, bore and chamber starting to rust in jungles and delta of Vietnam operation. In today market you most likely find Nitride instead of phosphate. If i am wrong, please feel free to correct me.Tagged: Stainless. Both are excellent finishes that are very hard, smooth and high performing. DLC outperforms nitride by about the same amount that nitride outperforms phosphate. This is on the basis of hardness and corrosion resistance. …. On the basis of bang for the buck, nitride wins.Hard coat anodize in the upper is around low to mid 60's C scale. Some of the PVD and Cvd coatings can be high 60's to low 80's. Parkerizing etches the surface and holds lube. A good parkerized carrier will out live the upper and the user. Craig. [ARCHIVED THREAD] - Chrome phosphate vs nitride - BCGs. ARCHIVED.The cold hammer forging process work hardens the steel around a rifled mandrel, which creates the lands and grooves. These barrels are chambered in 5.56mm NATO. The barrel is then chrome lined to the spec for a M249 Machine Gun barrel, which is about twice as thick as that of an M4 barrel. The end result is a rifle that can be run hard day ...Both finishes are durable. Nitride is not only coated on the exterior, but in the barrel's bore too. It permeates the metal to give better rust protection. Phosphate is only done on a barrel's exterior surface and not the bore. This is because mil-spec type barrels are chrome-lined first and chrome won't stick to phosphate or any other coating ...Coatings/treatments have come a LONG way since then. On a BCG, Phosphate will wear off quickly on the rails, leaving nothing but bare metal (kind of makes it pointless). Nitride does NOT wear off the rails (it is a treatment that permeates the surface). All of my BCG's are nitride. Easy to clean, slick, doesn't chip/peel.Location. Western Oregon. wind gypsy said: Cerakote only goes on outside. Obviously it is a bigger problem if the bore rusts (unless you're worried about cerakote matching the tone of your Kifaru royal green). That's what I figured. I'm less concerned with the corrosion on the outside of the barrel then the inside.MIL Anodizing vs Nitride Finish - Color Match. Hey everyone, Pardon my lack of experience here. I've only ever purchased completed firearms, and I'm buying separate uppers/lowers for the first time. I'm going to shell out a little extra cash for a completed upper with an M-Lok rail that has a nitride finish after reading it's superior to ...Ballistic Advantage nitride barrels were way more accurate than Faxons for me (both nitride). I own 4 BA barreled uppers and they are great for the money, especially from hot deals for +/- $125 My FN CHF barrels put my BCM CHF barrels to shame. BUT they are almost identical on paper 🤷🏼.Above: After 1100 rounds this Toolcraft BCG is filthy but the AR15 continues to run reliably. Black Nitride Finish. IMO, the Black Nitride finish is the best bang for the buck of the black BCG finishes. It is a super hard finish that runs smooth and is both easy to clean and easy on the wallet. For a comparison of the top 3 black BCG finishes ...Titanium Nitride (TiN) coated barrel. ... Partially what u/bjacks12 said, but it does help reduce wear on the barrel. Since I could get it done locally and rather inexpensively (look online, lots of places push $100-$150) I said fuck it, insurance. ... Wonder how it holds up compared to the Sig factory nitride or phosphate finishes.This drop-in AR-15 BCG features a corrosion resistant salt bath nitride finish, MIL-SPEC dimensions, and a magnetic particle inspected carpenter 158 steel bolt. Crafted from domestically sourced 8620 steel, the M16 cut carrier includes a gas key fastened by properly staked grade 8 screws.We speak with Nathanial from Faxon regarding barrels, barrel manufacturing, chrome lining versus nitride and more.If you're interested in learning what reall...Machined from 8620 steel. Carrier has forward assist serrations. Mil-Spec phosphate coating. Properly staked gas key. Chrome lined gas key and bolt channel. 5.56 Bolt is machined from Carpenter 158 tool steel. Shot peened. HPT tested/MPI marked. Black o-ring insert on extractor.Nitride vs Stainless Steel Barrel Price. When choosing a barrel for your AR-15, one aspect to consider is the price and availability of nitride and stainless steel barrels. Nitride barrels tend to be more affordable and easier to manufacture, which often results in lower costs for the end-user. However, exceptions do exist, and some nitride ...Ballistic Advantage nitride barrels were way more accurate than Faxons for me (both nitride). I own 4 BA barreled uppers and they are great for the money, especially from hot deals for +/- $125 My FN CHF barrels put my BCM CHF barrels to shame. BUT they are almost identical on paper 🤷🏼.Wrapped both barrels with damp cloths, and left sitting inside my house for 4 days. Results: See pics below. TLDR: Nitride barrel showed no signs of rust at all. Black oxide had minor rust, but only underneath the painters tape. Black oxide 48hrs. Noticed rust under the tape, and removed the tape.The hallmark of salt bath nitriding is the bath of molten salt (usually cyanide or other salts) into which parts are submerged. The method features the transfer via diffusion of carbon and nitrogen from the molten salt to the surface of a steel part. It remains a popular case hardening technique because it offers:Definitely not. Nitriding is a bit superior to chrome lining. Chrome lining adds material to the inside of the bore and tightens the throat, causing a slight decrease in accuracy. Melonite Nitriding is a chemical treatment that hardens and protects the bore without changing any of the original tolerances.May 9, 2019 · Bolt-carrier groups above, from left, represent Nickel Boron, phosphate (Palmetto State Armory), Robar NP3, black nitride and chrome-plate (Daniel Defense).Advances in gun coating technology can ...Although phosphate holds lubricant better than nitride, I think I like the nitride more. The thing with an ar 15 BCG is that the contact surfaces are actually pretty small, the whole carrier isnt being drug through the upper, and phosphate isnt a very hard wearing finish.and the other part of the conversation "...nitride is cheaper, better tolerances, easier to clean...". one topic that always gets touched on is nitride is easier to clean and CP (chrome phosphate) holds oil better, but the discussion usually stops there even though the threads go on for multiple pages, but that is the major take away. the only ...We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us.Curious that Geissele is now offering barrels. If they are actually available for sale, that is a good thing. Geissele makes their own barrels in house. The description says they are chrome lined with mag phosphate exterior. The only part they don't mention is what treatment/finish is on/in the barrel extension.Nitride is a change to the surface of the metal, and while not as slick as NiB, it's harder and cannot flake. It's usually slicker than phosphate, however. TiN is harder than nitride or NiB, but usually slicker than nitride. It's usually more expensive than either. I probably wouldn't pay $75 over a nitride version, but that's just me.The chemical formula for tin(II) nitride is Sn3N2. The chemical symbol Sn is used to represent tin, while the chemical symbol N is used to represent nitrogen. An ion is an element ...Nitride is easier to clean. While properly performed nitrocarburization treatment is great for a bolt carrier, it is a sub-par choice for the bolt. Reason being is that the nitriding process has the tendency to impart brittleness. This translates to decreased bolt life, usually significantly. The nitriding process involves submerging the steel ...Phosphate finishes are just a coating, the are rough on the surface and hold oil well. Better than paint, better than blued steel. Nitride finishes are actual surface treatments to the metal. The high temperature process diffuses nitrogen into the metal actually changing its structure. The surface left is very hard and very corrosion resistant ...This BCG features a C158 bolt, 4340 extractors, and an S7 tool steel ejector. The gas key is made out of 4130 steel, is chrome lined as it should be, and includes enhanced Sprinco extractor springs, a sealed gas key, and properly staked gas key screws. The carrier is made out of 8620 steel and has a phosphate finish with a chrome-lined bore.

There are 31 pitchers of beer in a half-barrel, assuming one pitcher is 64 ounces, and one barrel is 31 gallons. One gallon is 128 ounces, so a half-barrel is 1,984 ounces of beer....I was wondering if if the difference matters between gas block finishes (nitride vs phosphate). All the nitride finish Aero gas blocks are sold out and the last two parts I need for my 6.5 build is a tube and block. Just was curious if you guys had any advice on whether or not it matters for the gas block. Thanks! I’d get an adjustable.Nitride is significantly less expensive and less time-consuming for making barrels. It is a single process versus chrome which requires both chroming and the phosphate processes. Is Nitride the same as Melonite, Isonite, Fenocite, QPQ? Faxon typically uses the terms “nitride” and “QPQ” to refer to how our barrels are processed ...Absolutely untrue. We have been nitride treating for decades forged steel crankshaft main bearing journals and rod bearing journals on 7,000 rpm 500+ horsepower racing engines. This is done to increase surface hardness to reduce wear under extreme stress and pressure. The forged steel does not lose its strength.308 Barrel Kit (18″ or 20″) $ 475.00. Review financing options. Price $ 475.00. Add to cart. Shipping & Returns. Return Authorization is required for all returned merchandise. Please email [email protected] or call 407.928.2666 to acquire a Return Merchandise Authorization Number (RMA.) Review our complete Return Policy.

Handgun barrels: $40.00. Rifle and Shotgun barrels: $60.00. Double (O/U, SxS)* Shotgun barrels: $65.00. .50 Cal. extra heavy bull barrels: $85.00. Receiver: $12.50. 3 Choke tubes: $12.50. Please note that older O/U and SxS shotguns with soft-soldered barrels should not be subject to this process. All pricing subject to a $95.00 minimum lot charge.Nitride vs Phosphate. PSA ProductsAR-15. MichaelAnthony October 28, 2022, 4:55am 10. well you basically have three options nitride, phosphate, and fancy phosphate… phosphate soaks up the lube you use really well and if well maintained some people prefer them… otherwise nitride is just less maintenance, less likely to have issues with ...I would recommend nitride if you have the option. However, phosphate barrels look better with an a2 front sight and standard handguards, as the nitride barrels have a shiny …Salt Bath Nitriding (DHSN) Salt Bath Nitriding/Nitrocarburizing was originally created as an alternative to gas nitriding that would produce a more uniform case through surface contact between the substrate and liquid salt. When steel parts are placed into a preheated liquid salt, there is sufficient energy localized near the surface due to ...Nitride is easier to clean. While properly performed nitrocarburization treatment is great for a bolt carrier, it is a sub-par choice for the bolt. Reason being is that the nitriding process has the tendency to impart brittleness. This translates to decreased bolt life, usually significantly. The nitriding process involves submerging the steel ...Though it can be more expensive than a phosphate coating, black nitride has a shiny black aesthetic that offers superior performance, too. Nickel Boron Nickel boron-coated bolt carrier groups look like hard chrome BCGs, but they are actually produced through an electroless plating process that leaves a finish on the surface of the BCG that …Looking for a product featured in this video? YouTube prevents us from posting links. Head over to our website to find what you're looking for.Check out our ...I have been researching the above 3 gun barrels and have narrowed my 3 choices to CVA Accura V2, T/C Bone Collector, Traditions Strikerfire. I currently own a .45 cal and would like to purchase a .50 cal. The CVA Bergara Nitride barrel is advertised as guaranteed rust proof. Does anyone have experience or suggestions on any of these guns?It has their QPQ finish which is essentially a nitride treatment. QPQ is quench, polish, quench. It is extremely slick and cleans up with the wipe of a rag. DLC on the other hand is a coating as is hard chrome. Nitride is a surface treatment. Any of them are superior to phosphate. Posted: 9/15/2019 11:22:57 AM EDT.Phosphate > chrome lined > chrome line bore and chamber. The barrel, bore and chamber starting to rust in jungles and delta of Vietnam operation. In today market you most likely find Nitride instead of phosphate. If i am wrong, please feel free to correct me.Carbine gas ensures any loads will cycle quickly and smoothly, and a mil-spec parts kit with Carbine buffer and M4-type buttstock finishes off the kit. Stainless steel vs parkerized barrel. The US military does buy stainless barrels; but, that's what may be available. Nitride barrels have a smoother bore, which results in more consistent shots.Phosphate is essentially parkerization, nitride is harder and more corrosion resistant. Chrome lining is a superior bore treatment - by a little bit and for some use cases - but phosphate is a vastly inferior exterior treatment for longevity and corrosion. And because it is two processes, it costs more vs 1 single process for nitriding.3451 posts · Joined 2017. #6 · Aug 25, 2018. sounds like the Polish Radom barrels made on the Steyr-Mannlicher equipment would be a good choice, as they are hammer-forged and chrome-lined. unless I'm mistaken, both Arms of America and AK Builder have them. also I think they run about $165-$170.Nitride is significantly less expensive and less time-consuming for making barrels. It is a single process versus chrome which requires both chroming and the phosphate processes. Is Nitride the same as Melonite, Isonite, Fenocite, QPQ? Faxon typically uses the terms “nitride” and “QPQ” to refer to how our barrels are processed ...Personally, Nitride. Sure, you won't have to do daily oiling on the phosphate, but you can simply forget about the nitride. I have exactly 1 phosphate barrel that's still installed on my first AR from 2003 and I have to remind myself to run a wet patch down the barrel every other month or so to keep it from rusting.Feedback: 0 / 0 / 0. Dec 22, 2014. #3/21. I like the nickel boron that I have used for the past year.Easy to keep clean and shows very little wear.Just purchased a black nitride for a new build.Instructed to use extra lube with the first 600 rounds break in,then ok to run dry.Time will be the judge!Chrome lining handles heat and long term wear above and beyond Nitriding or any other bore finish options. Nitrided and regular 416r stainless can achieve better accuracy much easier than chrome lining. Nitride and chrome have their advantages and disadvantages. One of chrome's being the exterior finish coupled with it is usually not the greatest.Everything I have read about the ak-74 is that all the barrels are 4150 CMV Nitride inside and out. I haven’t seen one of these PSA ak-74’s in person, but all the reviews I’ve seen and read from people owning them and reviewing them here on the PSA forums/Reddit seems like everyone has gotten them with the inside and outside finish …Toolcraft Phosphate BCG. This is a very Mil-Spec BCG that won’t win beauty awards, but it runs. Mil-Spec Carpenter 158 bolt, chrome lined carrier, chrome lined gas key made to USGI specs, and a staked gas key. MSRP is only $150, but you’ll almost always find these for about $99.Published by Dustin Babich on 31 May 2023. A parkerized barrel is a type of firearm barrel that has been treated with a phosphate coating, resulting in increased resistance to corrosion and wear. The process of parkerization involves applying a layer of zinc or manganese phosphate to the surface of the barrel through a chemical reaction.Nitride is also much better than phosphate for the BCG. Phosphate is just too rough. Nitride has a very smooth almost polished finish that is much easier to clean and slides in the upper much easier. Posted: 1/3/2021 2:15:10 PM EDT. [#12] Quote History. Quoted:Nitride is a harder and slicker finish than phosphate. Nitride will wear better, last longer, and have less friction than phosphate. There's a reason metal cutting tools (end mills, boring bar inserts, etc) have nitride coatings instead of phosphate. View Quote. There is very minimal wear surface on a bolt carier.Stag 10 16" Barrel in .308 with 1:10 Twist Rate - Mid-Length - Nitride. This Stag 10 barrel is chambered in .308 and with a lightweight profile. Finished in black nitride for strength & longevity and coming in at 16" this barrel is incredibly accurate and light enough to make all-day carry a breeze. This barrel will function with both Stag 10 ...